top of page

Technical Note: In violation of a TSE resolution, YouTube recommends videos of candidates to voters

Oct 24
2 min read

Recommendation systems on digital platforms select and organize the content presented to users, influencing which videos, profiles, and channels gain visibility. In the electoral context, this form of content curation is particularly relevant, as it can help determine which candidates gain visibility and influence voters’ exposure to political and electoral content that they did not necessarily seek out.


In Brazil, this issue was incorporated more explicitly into electoral regulations through Resolution No. 23,732/2024 of the Superior Electoral Court (TSE). This regulation stipulates that pages, channels, and profiles used by candidates must be reported to the Electoral Court and prohibits providers that use recommendation systems from presenting these channels to users in sections and feeds featuring organic content suggestions. The rule aims to prevent a candidate’s reach from depending on the platforms’ algorithmic choices, thereby ensuring a level playing field among candidates.


Given the widespread non-compliance with the rule prohibiting platforms such as X and TikTok from recommending candidates, NetLab UFRJ also examined YouTube’s implementation of these measures. The analysis focuses on short videos (Shorts), seeking to verify whether content published by candidates’ profiles is recommended and to identify situations in which campaigns use YouTube profiles that were not reported to the TSE but are recommended by the platform.


We conducted a systematic observation of video recommendations displayed on YouTube Shorts between September 26 and October 4, 2026, based on the browsing behavior of three user profiles (personas)—one supportive of Flávio Bolsonaro, one supportive of Lula, and a control persona who did not consume political content. The recommended channels were compared with the registry of candidates’ social media accounts maintained by the TSE (Superior Electoral Court [TSE], 2026b) to determine whether the platform suggested candidates’ posts to users during the campaign. The analysis considered both the profiles listed by the TSE—which, therefore, should not have been recommended to users—and those used by candidates to post campaign content but not reported to the Electoral Court.


The analysis identified 44 content recommendations from 26 candidate profiles whose URLs appeared in the TSE registry, in violation of the rule requiring the exclusion of these profiles and their content from recommendation system results. Among the cases identified were the channels of Lula and Flávio Bolsonaro, presidential candidates.


In addition to these cases, a comparison between the recommended channels and TSE data identified seven official channels registered with a URL different from the one reported to the Electoral Court or promoting candidates who had not registered their YouTube channels.


Read the report




DATA ACCESS

If you wish to access the database for this report, please send an email to netlab@eco.ufrj.br identifying yourself, explaining the reason for your interest in the data and how it will be used. NetLab will evaluate your request and contact you.

 


WARNING

This report is an independent production of NetLab UFRJ. All decisions regarding this work were made exclusively by the researchers of the laboratory. The funders of NetLab UFRJ have no influence over the laboratory's research agenda and did not participate in any stage of the production of this report.


Information about the funding sources of NetLab UFRJ is available here.

 
 
bottom of page